S2, E18: Building a Fantasy Tavern in Salt Lake - Thieves Guild
Salt Lake City’s bar scene used to feel interchangeable, but Thieves Guild Cidery shows what happens when a place is built for a specific community. The founders talk about creating a fantasy tavern where people can actually stay for hours, play board games, and feel at home even if they never liked “normal” bars. That sense of belonging is the real product, and it’s why a niche concept can outperform generic nightlife. For anyone searching “unique bars in Salt Lake City” or “things to do downtown Salt Lake,” a themed, activity-driven space changes the whole night.
The story starts with nerd culture that predates the mainstream boom: Warcraft, StarCraft, Diablo, trading card games, anime, and the slow shift to a world where being passionate is finally cool. That background matters because Thieves Guild isn’t just Skyrim decor and Lord of the Rings vibes. It’s a “nerd bar” in the broad sense: a third place for fandoms of all kinds, from Dungeons and Dragons groups to Warhammer painters to anime dance nights. The episode makes the case that the label “nerd” is really about unashamed enthusiasm, and the bar is designed to reward it.
On the business side, they trace the path from home cider making to real production, including learning the brutal truth that fermentation does not scale linearly. They brewed heavily during COVID, then built a plan with dense Excel modeling, consulted experienced industry folks, and got the validating stamp that they weren’t “complete idiots.” The leap from five-gallon batches to hundreds of gallons required process control, equipment decisions, and a willingness to be humbled by temperature swings and production constraints. For listeners interested in entrepreneurship, craft cider, or starting a taproom in Utah, the episode is a practical look at risk, research, and momentum.
The design story is pure DIY: 3D modeling, printing, sanding, painting, soldering, microcontrollers, and lighting effects built in-house because outsourcing couldn’t match the vision. They describe the frustration of trying to explain a D&D tavern aesthetic to typical “industrial chic” designers, and why doing it themselves made the space feel authentic rather than staged. Even the bathrooms become part of the world-building, from a dark, dramatic Ministry of Magic-inspired room to “Paperback Paradise” wallpapered with hilarious altered fantasy pulp covers. It’s a reminder that memorable hospitality is often obsessive detail, not expensive finishings.
Looking forward, they’re focused on scaling craft cider output, expanding canned releases, and placing cans in other Salt Lake City bars rather than cloning the entire venue. They also talk about Apples and Daggers, their birthday festival that aims to become a proper adult renn fair with vendors, chaos, and a tankard in hand. The bigger takeaway is simple: don’t dilute the weird idea, commit to it with craft and care, and the right people will show up and bring loot, stories, and friends who finally have “their place.”
Listen to full episode :
